Iranian Journal of Toxicology
Reviewer’s Evaluation Form
Dear Reviewer,
The IJT Editorial Board appreciates your valuable contribution to the quality of IJT publications. Upon completion of your review for each manuscript, please complete this form and send it to the Journal’s Editorial office by E-mail as an attachment at the following address: ijtarakmu.ac.ir
TITLE: Is the title appropriate? Yes □ No □ Why not? …………………..............………………............
ABSTRACT: Does it fit the study? Yes □ No □ Why not? ……………..………….……..........……………….
INTRODUCTION:
- It presents the state-of-the-art for the topic. Yes □ No □
- It presents important studies that have been done on the topic. Yes □ No □
- It provides sound reasons for conducting the current study. Yes □ No □
- It provides specific aims for conducting the current study. Yes □ No □
MATERIALS & METHODS:
- The materials are defined correctly. Yes □ No □
- The methods are appropriate for the study. Yes □ No □ Why not? ……………..………….…
- The sampling and/or subject recruitment is/are appropriate. Yes □ No □
- The data collection is appropriate. Yes □ No □ Why not? ……………….…….….......….…..……
- The data analysis is appropriate. Yes □ No □ Why not? ……………....…..………..………….…
RESULTS:
- The results conform to the study objectives. Yes □ No □
- They are described clearly and adequately. Yes □ No □
- Tables and figures conform to the study data. Yes □ No □
DISCUSSION:
- Results are interpreted appropriately. Yes □ No □
- Findings are compared or contrasted with appropriate studies. Yes □ No □
- Future directions have been offered to explore the topic further. Yes □ No □
CONCLUSIONS:
Conclusions are relevant to the study findings. Yes □ No □
REFERENCES: The cited references are relevant to the subject. Yes □ No □
PLAGIARISM: No indication of plagiarism was found. Agree □ Disagree □: If disagree, contact the Editor.
REVIEWER’S FINAL RECOMMENDATION:
- ACCEPT for publication without revisions □
- ACCEPT for publication with minor revisions □
- ACCEPT for publication with major revisions □
- REJECT for publication □
Reviewer’s Name: ……............……....………… Signature: ……............…...…………….. Date: ……......…....………..
Please print the completed form, write your name, sign and date the form, and E-mail it to the Editorial Office at: ijtarakmu.ac.ir
Click here to print
|